USE OUR LISTS – FINDING THE RIGHT BALANCE BETWEEN READING LEVEL AND CONTENT IS KEY
We want to make sure that we do not aim too high or too low with regard to reading level and content. Books that are too babyish will be insulting and books that are too complicated will be a turn off. The only exception to this is that kids often want to read stories that are too mature or edgy for their age. A fairly good rule of thumb is that the protagonist of the book should be the same age or slightly older than the reader. For example a sixth grader probably does not want to read about a 9 year old but also should probably not being reading books with teenage characters. This is tricky because the reading levels of some of the mature titles are sometimes very easy. Therefore, it is not a matter of a younger child being unable to read the book but the content may be way too sophisticated and inappropriate. There are always exceptions to every rule and ultimately as parents we need to use our best judgment. To help you with this, we have divided our lists into 5 categories.
For Tweens and Teens we have divided books into two lists, Grade 5 and Up and Grade 8 and Up. (Ideally we would have a totally separate list for 7th graders because they saddle these ranges. My recommendation for 7th graders is that they stick with the 5th and up lists until midway through their 7th grade year and then they can transition to the older lists.
For pre-schoolers and up, we start with Picture Books which are not only great as read-alouds but can also be used for kids who are just starting to learn to read. First Chapter Books are for kids in K-2. These are longer books which oftentimes do have pictures but the emphasis is on the text. Our Middle Readers list contain chapter books that are longer and more sophisticated and are best for 3rd and 4th graders. Since you know your kid(s) best, you will be able to select the right list. Even if your child is in a particular grade, you may want to select a different list that you feel better meets your kid’s individual needs.